Blue Mountain Heights

499 W 158th St, New York, NY 10032, United States
Appearance
Blue Mountain Heights
links1234 linksdet1234
Comments
Sa
Review №1

Arrived 7:30 pm 4/22/24 . Was greeted & sat at the bar by a young pretty female. It was 6 of us . Spot was empty ( it’s Monday ). Unsure if it’s usually busy any other day. The girl was on FT - facetime the entire time we were there . We ordered drinks I had a rum punch rate that a 5/10 could’ve been WAY better. The food was 7/10 for me I loved the oxtail Rasta pasta . It was suppose to be mild but the oxtails were a bit spicy ( not too much ). It was only one chef n the back. The bartender/waitress was all over the place like it wasn’t that kind of day for her to be working. One of the people I was with ordered fried shrimp which came out after we were all half way done eating smh . She didn’t even set out any utensils to our food came. Definitely the type of spot u eat in and dnt order on Uber eats it’s fresher that way. Quiet in the wall spot I will say ( NO HOOKAH ).

An
Review №2

The waitress Ice was really nice but they gave me these two baby brown stew pieces of chicken. Highly disappointed. For $20 should have been more. Always wanted to try their food and did. There are several other places in Harlem where you get more food

K
Review №3

DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE ! I ordered through Uber eats and when I got my food let me tell you the chicken had so much f&$king hair on it ! Literally inedible. Blue mountain cafe should literally be ashamed not only did you not examine your chicken you also failed to clean it ! I will never order from here again. As you can see from the pictures how long , thick and disgustingly dirty the chicken is you shouldn’t be ordering from here either. Y’all give Jamaican restaurants a bad name.

La
Review №4

Ive ordered food indoors and for take out and it’s absolutely amazing. Glad spice level and flavor wasn’t altered to appeal out of culture people. 😅 Food and drinks are great and worth price point compared to other places that water down drinks and less flavored food.

Al
Review №5

This place is so good it reminded me of a home cooked meal. The vibe, music, and coziness really makes this place special and will make you wanting to come back for more. I ordered the Henny chicken which was the best Ive had since Ive moved to NY. With oxtail gravy on rice with a side of veggies. The only thing I regret is not ordering a drink :)

at
Review №6

First time at this restaurant it came highly recommended I’m fairly disappointed the mac & cheese is a one that’s kind of reminded me of craft with extra cheese however the oxtails are great perfect spiciness the plantains were very skimpy and the rice and peas were OK I will not be frequenting this place thanks though

No
Review №7

Very disappointed. I’ve been in the states for 10months and haven’t had Jamaican food. Imagine my excitement when I did a google search n realized there is a J’can restaurant close to where I just moved🙃. The excitement didn’t last long. When I got home n started eating the jerk chicken, with each bite I took the less I wanted the food. All you taste is PEPPER, NO FLAVOR. Didn’t take me back home at all; I wanted to cry… just being away from your home country craving this for months to finally get it and it’s just not hitting.Eating and your mouth is tingling is nice because I love spicy food, but spicy without flavor makes no sense.The rice and peas and steamed cabbage is just okay.Maybe get someone who is an expert in Jamaican cuisines, I could taste that the jerk seasoning was an authentic Jamaican/Caribbean brand, but the meal itself is way too tasteless to be a Jamaican dish. Yes, a lot of Jamaicans love spicy, but the spicy should be an add touch to the meal not the makeup.The restaurant setup is lovely, the lady in the front is very pleasant and hospitable, music in the background was nice… Just do better with the food.

Pa
Review №8

I dine here almost every other week, the food is always fresh, great portion and amazing taste. Their fish meals are amazing it is made fresh. The ambiance is nice and peaceful love it here!

Th
Review №9

Im so speechless this place is totally awesome...the food is to die for and the chef James his hands is heaven sent. Me and my wife simply love this place its very pleasant and relaxing. The bartender Jazmyn is amazing sure knows how to mix a drink nothing less then 5 stars, amazing place, amazing food, amazing staff very courteous and out of this world!!!

T
Review №10

Ordered on Uber eats a little disappointed, food is spicy. Barely can enjoy it with the level of spice. I expected rice n peas and they sent white rice , food was cold upon arrival .

Pa
Review №11

I arrived in New York, and this time, I did not want a deli anything. I found Blue Mountain Heights, which was walking distance from the place that I was lodging in. Decided to take a chance on them. The food was good, not as heavily flavored as I would expect for a West Indian restaurant. Still, the food was good. I did go there twice during my last trip. So that should say something about it. The customer service both trips was phenomenal and engaging. Overall, I am happy with Blue Mountain.

Ji
Review №12

I popped into this cozy spot for the first time yesterday and ordered a drink. I cant remember which mixed drink it was, but it was excellent and a good size. Then I settled into a window both and relaxed with the soothing sound of old school reggae (mostly Bob Marley) playing. A few regulars came in and were friendly enough. The music also wasnt too loud. Just a chill spot to have a drink and look at my phone. Ill be back.

Ch
Review №13

First and foremost I have to say that I have never in my life been to a Caribbean restaurant and the service was outstanding! The bartender was awesome the drinks were on point. The atmosphere was so welcoming. I wish I would of taken a picture of my food but we were to drunk by the time we got home and bodied that food!!! The rasta pasta was so fresh my man had chicken I had it with oxtail and it was great!!!This place is definitely a hidden gem!!!

In
Review №14

My new favorite spot! I ordered takeout: Oxtails, rice and peas, and mac and cheese. Delicious 😋 And thanks for the movie recommendation!

Mi
Review №15

Okay so I always check reviews but never leave them But THIS PLACEEEE!! Absolutely deserves one. The food is amazing, done fast, the employees are friendly and radiant, love it here. Absolutely go here if your looking for some good Caribbean food and drinks

CJ
Review №16

Stopped by for a crew lunch after a shoot at Sisters Uptown Book Store (another gem) and the food was delicious. Everyone who was a part of our party of 8 thoroughly enjoyed our meals. I had the oxtails. They were slamming. And the food was hot and freshly prepared. We all cleaned our plates.This is an awesome find! Will definitely be going back! Having drinks next time!

Vi
Review №17

Good is Great. I ordered the Oxtails with rice and peas and it was kind of fatty but delicious. Their pepper shrimp is the best. Then I went yesterday and ordered Jerk Chicken platter and it was good also. Jasmine works at the bar and she’s amazing even though I didn’t drink.

Si
Review №18

My wife and I visited Blue Mountain Heights for her birthday and I must say that the food was amazing. The oxtails were delicious along with the mixed vegetables and mac and cheese. My wife love the chicken rasta pasta. The food came at a timely fashion and the waitress made sure we were good the entire time. The atmosphere was nice and cozy also. We left satisfied and full lol. We recommend this restaurant and will definitely be returning back soon.

za
Review №19

Amazing food and drinks at great prices. Best staff you will ever meet. Highly recommend

An
Review №20

I ordered through Uber eats. I was told that my meal was a large. When I got the food it was far from large and just oxtail bones! I do my best to support black business but this has really broken the camels back for me. They charged me $37.00 for nothing. I don’t like when I spend my money and people take advantage, but I do know that the more you take from others. You will lose the most! I am so bothered by this!

Ke
Review №21

This isn’t Jamaican food, I’m not sure what it is but it isn’t plus the woman who are regulars there have the nerve to be fighting other women that they don’t even know just because they are intimidated by new comers and young beauty. Goodbye food is nasty anyway

Ch
Review №22

I order the Rasta pasta and added chicken to it and the chicken taco, - they gave me Rasta pasta with like pieces of, I believed to me, it looked like jerk chicken was added to the pasta, and the chicken, which the menu never specified that it would be that type of chicken in both the Rasta pasta and the Chicken taco and it made everything too spicy and like they tried to make a hard shell taco out of a soft shell taco and that made it hard to bit into and chewy...and for the Rasta pasta too oily and to dam spicy....I m good..wont be ordering here anymore.

Ne
Review №23

I ordered Snapper steamed, with rice and peas and mixed veggies. I dont think the fish they gave me was snapper. In addition it tasted like they steamed it while it was still frozen so it didnt absorb any flavor. The texture was all wrong and it had a strong fish odor. I tried to cut it with the lime and lemon but in the end I couldnt eat it.The fried, ripe plantains were very oily, tasted like they started it in cold oil. Overall disappointing

Ya
Review №24

Just ordered for Delivery. Evry plate came intact. I ordered oxtail and bbq wings.The oxtail has the perfect spiciness. The wings was very very spicy but good. I recommend and will order again!I ORDERED AGAIN LIKE A WEEK AFTER!Im pregnant, cant wait to give birth to actually go to the restaurant.

Ja
Review №25

Got food to go and jasmine was very friendly.10/10 everything we had was amazing. 100% will be back.

Ma
Review №26

This is THE Jamaican spot to eat at. Everything Ive tried tasted amazing especially the rasta pasta with curry chicken ( I drool at the thought of that plate). This place hits the mark every single time I go in and the staff is super sweet. The ambience they create is homely. Between the food and the service I fight to leave lol. I would definitely recommend trying g it

de
Review №27

I have not had jerk chicken and rice and peas this good in a long time. Good music and nice vibe. I would have loved to dine in, but the AC didnt seem to be working very well. Staff was super friendly and helpful.

Kr
Review №28

Jerk chicken empanadas and oxtail are the best. Food has a good spice to it. I ordered n Uber eats.

Ro
Review №29

Food is delicious. Some of the best Jamaican food I have ever had.

Ni
Review №30

Ordered for delivery for the first time. Rasta pasta w/ shrimp was not impressive and extremelyyyy salty. The cheesecake I wanted was unavailable and even though the restaurant called me to confirm they would give me a different flavor, there was no cheesecake in the bag. Will not be ordering again.

Am
Review №31

✨ All Henny, all evening ✨Incredible food and amazing service.

Ni
Review №32

Food is flavorful and drinks are AMAZING! Bartenders are friendly. However, it is COLD in the restaurant. Uncomfortably, cold. I hope they get a heating system soon.

Cl
Review №33

Great experience and service. Nice music, food was amazing and the drinks, oh the drinks. Went there for one cocktail and had like 4 plus Jamaican Rum Shots.

Am
Review №34

Great cook, exceptional food and most of all Jazzy the bartender makes phenomenal drinks! Her customer service skills is on point. Will definitely recommend this place to everyone and will be returning for sure. 👍👍🙏💗

Mr
Review №35

First lemme say I ordered through GRUBHUB second EVER both bad experiences!Food was cold the pepper shrimp was good but cold and so were the other meals ordered! BUT THE FOOD WAS GREAT!!! Yesss then the other part was I ordered extra plantains I NEVER received called the business was directed towards GRUBHUB reached out to them, only be RE DIRETED to the business!!! #Badbusiness that’s why I’m giving a low grade for this establishment and towards Grubhub

al
Review №36

Wow their rasta pasta is out of this world

ba
Review №37

This was my first time there, very clean 👌 friendly 👌 and the food menu was nice. They serve drinks 🍸 but the only thing is that they close alittle early on Friday and Saturday. But a very nice place.

X
Review №38

I grabbed the curry chicken for take out that was SO DELICIOUS! Right down to the salad. The staff was so kind, deff coming back to sit and enjoy them more

Ka
Review №39

CURRY CHICKEN GOES CRAZYYY!!! WAS SOO GOOD!! FELT LIKE I WAS ON THE ISLAND NO!! WENT BACK NEXT DAY FOR THE OXTAILS AND ALMOST DIED IT WAS SOOOO GO!!!! WOULD WALK 100 BLOCKS FOR IT!!!

We
Review №40

Amazing fool had some crab legs from out of this wirld

TH
Review №41

Love it here and the rum Punch is great

An
Review №42

One of the better West Indian restaurants in Harlem. Was pleasantly shocked!!

La
Review №43

Absolutely amazing ! Food is fresh always, The servers and the bartenders a very nice and the drinks ? BABY ! Get me right every time lol. So if you tryna chill and eat great food THIS THE SPOT ❤️

mi
Review №44

Food was amazingly tasteful‼️ The rum punch was excellent 🙌🏾 Can’t wait to got back.

Va
Review №45

A lovely restaurant/bar youll probably want to visit often. Both the food and drinks were good. Friendly service too. Another place well frequent...a local gem!

Ro
Review №46

Some of the best food Ive had in the fifteen years Ive been in this city. Great service, fun atmosphere.

Ja
Review №47

Amazing place, staff is soooo chill and friendly! Food is awesome and drinks are strong and cheap!

ka
Review №48

Great atmosphere, great food and drinks at a good price!!

ma
Review №49

Best rum punch ever and the food is to die for

Re
Review №50

Awesome staff. They have an espresso machine! Im honestly addicted to the Rasta pasta and rum punch. Only complaint is i wish they were open later.

De
Review №51

This place is awesome! The pepper shrimp is soo goood. Also recommend the jerk chicken. Really friendly and attentive staff and reasonable prices.

Ai
Review №52

The oxtails is literally the best oxtail i ever had🔥it’s flavorful not too sweet not burnt just cooked to perfection. the mac was really good and cheesy 10/10 i highly recommend.

Jo
Review №53

Great food! Drinks are a little pricey and it took about an hour to get my food. Otherwise, I would give them 5 stars

Da
Review №54

We ordered four meals and have been waiting for an hour with no food in sight. Ridiculous when we have somewhere to be. I hear the food is great but it doesn’t look like we’ll have a chance to find out.

Na
Review №55

Great hospitality. food was tasty and delicious. customer service was lovely. my date had a great time.

Jo
Review №56

The food is amazing and I plan on coming back as much as I can. Food is fresh and the bartenders are great with making drinks. 💯💯💯

po
Review №57

I love the hospitality here I always get Rasta pasta spicy it’s so yummy with a Henny punch

Ma
Review №58

Worst seamless experience ever. No one picks up the phone, food takes over an hour just to prepare and I can’t reach anyone to cancel my order. Just hungry and annoyed is all I can say about Blue Mountain Heights.

So
Review №59

Closed when I arrived although I paid for food online. Closed over an hour early and wondering if still in business.

La
Review №60

Food is always good. The staff is always polite.

Ho
Review №61

Jerk chicken was not good at all Mac and cheese not good this is not even close to jerk chicken I wish I had read the review before I went to the restaurant

Sh
Review №62

Food-amazingly tasty. The chefs can cook!!!!! Nice service. Drinks-good and strong thank you we will definitely return!!!!!!

An
Review №63

Great Jamaican food awesome ambiance

Ra
Review №64

Drinks are over priced. I ordered a virgin drink. No liquor. $8.00! I must say, that punch was good though.

An
Review №65

I spent a very pleasant afternoon with friends at Blue Mountain Heights Cafe, a small Caribbean restaurant in the Washington Heights area of Manhattan. The restaurant is cozy and inviting with outdoor seating available on warm days. There is a fully stocked bar and reggae music playing in the background to enhance the island vibe of the restaurant.We ordered a number of appetizers and entrees. The jerk wings, shrimp salad, chicken tacos and peppered shrimps were all very tasty. The jerk chicken and Oxtail were well seasoned and delicious. The serving portions were also good. For dessert, we had both the Hennessy and Pistachio cheesecake which were amazing.Our server, Miriam, was a delight. She was very professional, personable and added to our wonderful experience at the restaurant.I would definitely recommend Blue Mountain Heights Cafe for their food and service.

Or
Review №66

1 of the best place to eat and have a drink. real authentic Jamaican food and service is second to none

Tr
Review №67

The food is delicious and the people are very friendly. This place never disappoints!!

Pe
Review №68

Delicious food. Quick and courteous service. Truly a gem to come back to again and again.

ST
Review №69

The restaurant served excellent food. The service was very good.

di
Review №70

This place has the best jamaican food,their RASTA PASTA is to die for!great food!

Mi
Review №71

The food is natural and fresh done to your desire delicious I definitely will be back

Ki
Review №72

OMG! Sooooooo good!

Mi
Review №73

Had jerk chicken and stewed chicken both orders were tasty had ad drinks 🍸 while waiting 😋 Ill be back

ha
Review №74

Food is excellent and have a drink with that meal very cozy in the cut spot

Je
Review №75

Can someone please tell me do they really open Because they seems to never be open, I see so many reviews and I don’t know how people get inside, because every time I go there within the time they post they are always close. I will change my stars if this place really is open and again how is people giving reviews I have been trying

Ky
Review №76

Blue Mountain Heights is awesome. The food is so good. Everyone should go here if you want a great meal.

st
Review №77

Delicious fresh food made to orderand Oral the owner is just delightful.

Wi
Review №78

Oxtail was so good I had a dream the same night. Everything was great to the point I forgot it was raining outside. My girlfriend enjoyed her food too. Nice place for a date.

Kw
Review №79

Best Curry 🍤 Shrimp Ever 😋 added to Great hospitality from Ricka 👍

HS
Review №80

Wherever I am in town, i go to this restaurant because the prices are affordable and the food is delicious. On a few occasions, i ordered the stew chicken, which my son loves. I was disappointed when i opened the container to see that there was no meat on the legs and thighs in the chicken stew. It was ALL bones, no meat. Its like the cook gave me what was left at the bottom of the pot.. Just being real!!!

Da
Review №81

Food and drink was great! Look forward to being a frequent customer!

Su
Review №82

The food is real good here and the service was great. Wonderful menu selection and their prices were really good too. Check them out if youre in the area.

Di
Review №83

I decided to go to this place today after work originally I had wanted the oxtail meal but the lady at the bar had told me it was gonna be an hour and a half wait I was a little bit disappointed but I decided to get a different meal she had recommended the garlic salmon which I got and I must say the food was good I also had gotten rice and peas and plantains.The bartender was very nice I would be coming back to this place again

Ja
Review №84

The time I went wasnt busy....Minimum waiting. But as always be aware of your surroundings.

Em
Review №85

Great staff, delicious food (like it spicy!). Oxtail was great.

Ta
Review №86

Awesome place great people food is fantastic. Parking sucks.

Ja
Review №87

Love the overall vibe at this spot! Great happy hour, and friendly bartenders. Always a good time.

Fa
Review №88

Don’t recommendThe food wasn’t tasty at all

ro
Review №89

The best spot to eat. Right in the hood. Seafood Fridays is a must.

An
Review №90

Decided to try a new restaurant & I am so disappointed. Spent $60 for straight spicy food, I never knew fried chicken could be seasoned so spicy unless you actually ordered buffalo wings. I had BBQ & Henny wings & I couldnt even give it to my son how spicy they were. The presentation was cool & looked like it was fried to perfection but they were all buffalo wings.Lets not even get into the oxtail....they literally gave the baby ends of the tail it was a toddlers plate with alot of rice & the level of spice on that was outrageous as well and they had the audacity to put gravy on everything so its not like you could of went around it. Forgot to take a picture how vexxed I was.I will never order from them again even after seeing all those mixxy reviews I still decided to try them out.No thank you!

Ir
Review №91

Food is always delicious, service is always slow. Needs more staff.

Er
Review №92

Easy take out

Review №93

Food always amazing! No matter the time of day or night! Service on point too! Highly recommend!

Ey
Review №94

Great food, a much needed spot for the neighborhood

Je
Review №95

Love this place, especially in the summer months. The food drinks and servers are Aamazing but geez it-be COLD in that place in the winter. Harlem, take your coats and leave’em ON! ❤️

Ni
Review №96

The veggies are fresh, the serving sizes are hearty, the spices are delicious, and the rum punch is the best Ive ever had. The staff are all super sweet and attentive. I cannot say enough good things about my experience. They are now set up to serve people outside and are following all the Covid-19 safety protocols so you should make this your first stop if youre ready to eat at a restaurant again. Im so glad I did! I highly recommend the tacos, which are more like a taco salad with a Jamaican twist.

Da
Review №97

Delicious food.

Th
Review №98

It was AMAZING - I had the stew chicken!!!~AniYa A.

Me
Review №99

Friendly cool atmosphere, very pleasant to customers, I recommend it.

Ra
Review №100

The food always hits❤️‍🔥🔥🥹🥹🙏🏽🙏🏽Yall sent extra rasta pasta and didnt even need to - Thank you 🥰

Mi
Review №101

Get the crabs worth every penny curry very mid not getting that again the jerk chicken is good mac and cheese very mid but still good place is kinda expensive but hey it’s Washington heights

Te
Review №102

What ever the owner have to do to keep the chef he better. The food was beyond amazing. I love eating out and been to almost every good restaurants in the city. This place is the best. I am a Chef myself so I am very critical about a clean restaurant,and great flavor. This place has it all. Even peeked in the kitchen,it is spotless. Authentic Jamaican food,been to Trinidad and Jamaica and I know this food would not disappointed people from the islands.

Ni
Review №103

Food is good but the service is where they fall short. Incredibly long wait times for pickup and delivery (well, let’s just say when they even have delivery because that’s slim to none) and they run out of food quickly. Tonight, after waiting an hour for my pickup order (even though I was quoted 15 minutes), I got home and dug into my food only to realize that my jerk chicken was ice cold. I’m definitely done giving this place chances.

Mr
Review №104

One star is definitely generous...I ordered a large brown stew chicken, received what looked like a small in my opinion...basically a large portion of rice, 2 1/2 ridiculously small pieces of chicken, didnt get a drumstick, thigh...basically two pieces of chunk chicken with barely any meat on it

Ja
Review №105

A treasure in the heights, and not just the amazing food (which is a masterful rendition of your traditional Jamaican fare; fresh, savory, and the Oxtail is just so droolworthy!), but the ambiance and the general care put into service, presentation and execution.Tried every platter on the menu and the Oxtail is king, but love their interpretation of Jerk Chicken as well.We are lucky to have this in Washington Heights, and highly suggest it!

El
Review №106

I highly recommend everyone try this spot! The service was impecable and the food was absolutely spot on! Delicious! I love the laid back and chill vibe too. Definitely going back!!!

me
Review №107

Such an amazing location for food and drinks! Looking for amazing Jamaican food in Harlem, this is the place to go. Thank you to my former Kindergartener who said I MUST go to her daddys restaurant....surely didnt disappoint!

Ra
Review №108

Its been a minute since but everytime I order , yall never miss🙌🏽🙌🏽Delivery got here faster than I expected too🤣Rasta pasta was on point though 👌🏽

Ol
Review №109

The food here is absolutely delicious. I got the jerk chicken, Mac & cheese and plantains, totally worth it. Will definitely be coming back!

ki
Review №110

I was in the area and starving . Being that I’m Caribbean , figure this would be perfect . However as I walked in there was a very energetic young lady who proceeded to tell me the owner just came in 15 min ago to start cooking . We went to order drinks and she advised what she can make and what she hasn’t made . The food was ok , very bland for a Caribbean spot .Word of advice maybe get some one who is more Caribbean to great and give that island feeling . Definitely didn’t feel that feel nor the food

Pe
Review №111

This place is literally a diamond in the rough. Food is excellent!!! Made fresh!You must have the patients to wait because cooking time may be 35-40 upon ordering, but well worth it!!!I highly recommend for jamaican food lovers or anyone looking to grab a bite of authentic jamaican cuisine!

Ni
Review №112

Food was good, but the service was very slow. It’s a nice Jamaican vibe, but I won’t be returning unfortunately due to the chef making inappropriate and uncomfortable comments about me “not ordering any more carbs“ and asking me to stand up to see if I look like I work out then saying I don’t as I was leaving the restaurant. Whether he was joking or not it’s disrespectful and not appropriate nor good customer service to comment on a woman’s weight or diet. What if I had an eating disorder? I’ve never experienced that at any restaurant especially since they typically want you to buy their food. It’s embarrassing and offputting.

Re
Review №113

This place is amazing. Great food, and great drinks, but more importantly great service. You must try the jerk chicken empanadas.

De
Review №114

Ordered from here for the first time and the food is fantastic. So much flavor going on and the service staff are amazing.

Da
Review №115

Great atmosphere, vibes and food. The best curry shrimp Ive ever had. This neighborhood is definitely in need of this place.

Si
Review №116

Had this place for dinner last night. Now I’m trying to figure out how to reorder! The Rasta Pasta was delicious, both the grilled shrimp and the oxtail Rasta pasta were on point! The chef was absolutely kind and detailed with each meal. Thank you!

Ta
Review №117

Called a week in advance to advice of a party of about 15 people for a graduation celebration. We arrived around 5:30pm happy started at 4 but we were not made aware of happy hour, they charged full priced drinks neither were we given menus or water when we arrived. At 6:59 we were then told oh happy hour ends in one minute we ONLY ordered appetizers ( wings and empanadas )and the food took 1 hour and half or more to come out. They brought some people at the time food out on the same plate even though the order was made separately. They never came back to refill water or ask if we needed napkins. Some of the plates were missing wings and that took another 45 minutes for them to make the missing food. Music is great but customer service is horrible and the chef never came out to apologize or put us at ease but he definitely came out and cut him self a slice of cake.

As
Review №118

EVERYTIME I TRY TO ORDER FROM GRUBHUB OR SEAMLESS THEY CANCEL THE ORDER BECAUSE THERE TOO BUSY. IDK WHOS FAULT IT WAS BUT I COULDNT EVEN GET A PHONE CALL TO INFORM ME THAT MY ORDER WAS CANCELLED.

Ka
Review №119

Strong drinks great food friendly staff! Loved it there.

Ch
Review №120

Visited Blue Mountain during its first week of opening and it definitely exceeded my expectations. This low-key spot offers great drinks, quality coffee, and exceptional Jamaican style dishes. Customer service is very attentive, friendly, and respectful. The vibe is laidback yet upscale, perfect go-to spot for a date or any other social gathering. Highly recommend if you want a legitimat Caribbean experience here in Washington Heights.

To
Review №121

Great drinks great food and the atmosphere is awesome. I would give 10 stars if I could, Im definitely coming back again.

Ho
Review №122

Ordered from here twice already the food is so good. Authentic Jamaican with a twist. The oxtails are so good. Just had the jerk chicken and it was amazing. Also had the pineapple chicken with pineapple waffles that will knock your socks off!!!

Pa
Review №123

Excellent Jamaican food in an upscale, inviting bar that makes it realllly hard for you to leave. Came in with a friend who lives in the neighborhood and as a born and raised Jamaican, i was pleasantly surprised by the offerings of our cuisine as well as local favorites as well. Definitely worth a visit if you’re in the neighborhood and don’t forget to try the rum punch. (The plater in my picture is available on Fridays)

Ca
Review №124

Clean, good service, and delicious food (very spicy).

Mi
Review №125

Extremely expensive , the portions are very, very, very small

sa
Review №126

The food is good sometimes but most of the time it feel like it’s been reheated that I’ve gotten from them

Be
Review №127

FOOD IS GREATTHE CHEF IS A GOOD COOKTHE BAR IS GOOD TOOI LOVE WHERE THE PLACE IS LOCATED ATTHANK YOU BLUE MOUNTAIN HEIGHTS

Yv
Review №128

My first time going there the food was absolutely delicious I had Henny wings, cabbage, plantain and rice and peas

je
Review №129

Drinks where over piece no alcohol food wait time was over an hour for pastelitios cute spot but drinks horrible 👎🏽

DJ
Review №130

Food was amazing, it surely hit the spot. The set up was great and wonderful subtle decor

Ka
Review №131

Delicious food, more people need to know about this restaurant. Eat here quickly before its packed!!!

If
Review №132

Excellent service by Ricka! Great curry chicken dish.

Sa
Review №133

The food is amazing and the hospitality is excellent!! Ill definitely be visiting again.

Ju
Review №134

Kind servers, great service. But the most important thing is, there seafood is amazzzing !

Je
Review №135

OMG!!!!!! The Jamaican food here is beyond!!! If you love jerk, oxtail &/or escavitch you should be on your way to Blue Mountain Heights right now!!!!!

Nx
Review №136

Hey guys this is a solid 4I don’t hand out free 4’sThis spot is good I don’t wanna review itI don’t want it flooded with people at happy hour Bc the happy hour is amazingBut the Henny wings for 5 dollars at happy hour hhhhmmmm hmmmmm!It is what it is I know I try to offer off menu items to the people who eat at restaurants I’ve reviewed and trust me the “Rasta Pasta” is amazing

ju
Review №137

Honestly, I think its the best food in the Heights. Try the Jerk Chicken or the Oxtail 😋

B
Review №138

Great food. Great vibes. Great service

Si
Review №139

By far the best oxtail Ive eaten in New York, definitely recommend.

Ri
Review №140

Food was good ,love there jerk chicken

Jo
Review №141

Never answers phone. No message on answering service. No Temporarily Closed signs or messages. Restaurant appears to be CLOSED.

Pi
Review №142

Friendly family atmosphere, good food and strong drinks!

YV
Review №143

The Rum punch is a real winner as well as the food

Ti
Review №144

Food was Fab!!! Bartender Kes and Chef Dee were Super Duper Amazing . Having Blue Mountain Height Cafe/Bar is in my neighborhood is for the greatest gift 🎁📌📌📌📌 #Amen

Review №145

Definitely a place to be for all things Caribbean

Li
Review №146

One of my favorite places ever!!

El
Review №147

Great food and wonderful staff

Ki
Review №148

Got extremely sick, right after it came out of everywhere.

Ti
Review №149

Had a good time love the food

TA
Review №150

Great drinks and food!

De
Review №151

The food is finger licking good

Ph
Review №152

Nice staff, good neighbourhood ambience

Ch
Review №153

Good food and drinks

pa
Review №154

Excellent atmosphere and food

Sa
Review №155

So good.

L
Review №156

Tasty food!

Ka
Review №157

Best jamaican food@!!

Ch
Review №158

Great food and service

Sh
Review №159

The food is AMAZING!!!!

Mu
Review №160

Excellent food

Ne
Review №161

Best Jerk chicken

Ja
Review №162

Food is always on point

Fl
Review №163

Friendly, delicious :)

In
Review №164

Soooooo good!

am
Review №165

Good rum punch

To
Review №166

Loved it

Ke
Review №167

The oxtails are fantastic

Ed
Review №168

Delicious Oxtails!!

Li
Review №169

Food is fresh

17
Review №170

Amazing

Je
Review №171

Okay

Ti
Review №172

We had dinner here this evening, and honestly it was very good, and the service was great, good atmosphere in the restaurant, very cool chef.

Va
Review №173

The best of the best.

Ma
Review №174

Excellent

Mo
Review №175

The discovery of Harlem

Information
94 Photos
175 Comments
4.2 Rating
  • Address:499 W 158th St, New York, NY 10032, United States
  • Phone:+1 646-998-5905
Categories
  • Bar
Working hours
  • Monday:1–10:30 PM
  • Tuesday:1–8 PM
  • Wednesday:1–10:30 PM
  • Thursday:1–10:30 PM
  • Friday:1–10:30 PM
  • Saturday:1–10:30 PM
  • Sunday:1–10:30 PM
Service options
  • Delivery:Yes
  • Takeaway:Yes
  • Dine-in:Yes
Highlights
  • Fast service:Yes
  • Fireplace:Yes
  • Live music:Yes
  • Sport:Yes
Popular for
  • Lunch:Yes
  • Dinner:Yes
  • Solo dining:Yes
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance:Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible seating:Yes
Offerings
  • Alcohol:Yes
  • Beer:Yes
  • Cocktails:Yes
  • Coffee:Yes
  • Comfort food:Yes
  • Happy-hour drinks:Yes
  • Happy-hour food:Yes
  • Late-night food:Yes
  • Quick bite:Yes
  • Small plates:Yes
  • Spirits:Yes
  • Vegetarian options:Yes
  • Wine:Yes
Dining options
  • Breakfast:Yes
  • Brunch:Yes
  • Lunch:Yes
  • Dinner:Yes
  • Dessert:Yes
  • Seating:Yes
Amenities
  • Bar on site:Yes
  • Toilets:Yes
  • Wi-Fi:Yes
  • Wi-Fi:Yes
Atmosphere
  • Casual:Yes
  • Cosy:Yes
  • Trendy:Yes
Crowd
  • Family friendly:Yes
  • Groups:Yes
  • Tourists:Yes
Planning
  • Accepts reservations:Yes
Payments
  • Credit cards:Yes
  • Debit cards:Yes
  • NFC mobile payments:Yes
  • Credit cards:Yes
Similar organizations